Liability for a Dog Bite When a Child is in Charge of the Dog

Determining liability for dog bites claims can be complex, especially when a child is in charge of the dog at the time of the incident. In Illinois, the law provides clear guidelines to establish responsibility and ensure victims receive appropriate compensation. This article explores who can be held liable in such scenarios and the relevant legal principles that apply.

General Liability for Dog Bites in Illinois

Under Illinois law, dog owners are generally held strictly liable for injuries caused by their dogs, as stated in the Animal Control Act. This means that if a dog bites someone without provocation, the owner is responsible for the damages, regardless of whether the owner was negligent or knew of the dog’s propensity to bite.

Key Elements of the Illinois Animal Control Act

To establish liability under the Illinois Animal Control Act, the victim must prove the following:

  1. Injury: The victim suffered injuries caused by the dog.
  2. Lack of Provocation: The victim did not provoke the dog.
  3. Lawful Presence: The victim was lawfully on the property where the bite occurred.
  4. Ownership or Control: The defendant owned or controlled the dog at the time of the

When a Child is in Charge of the Dog

When a child is responsible for the dog at the time of the bite, determining liability can involve additional considerations. Here are the main parties who might be held liable:

  1. The Dog Owner
    • Strict Liability: The dog owner is typically held strictly liable under the Illinois Animal Control Act, regardless of who was supervising the dog at the time. The owner’s responsibility for the dog’s actions does not diminish simply because a child was in charge of the dog.
    • Example: If a neighbor’s child is playing with the owner’s dog and the dog bites someone, the dog owner can still be held liable for the injuries.
  2. The Child’s Parents or Guardians
    • Negligence: In some cases, the child’s parents or guardians might be held liable if it can be shown that they were negligent in supervising the child and the dog. This is particularly relevant if the child was too young to handle the dog safely or if the parents knew the dog had a history of aggression.
    • Example: If parents leave a young child alone with a large, aggressive dog, and the dog bites someone, the parents could be found negligent for failing to properly supervise the situation.
  3. The Property Owner
    • Premises Liability: If the dog bite occurs on the property of someone other than the dog’s owner, the property owner might be liable under premises liability principles. This typically applies if the property owner knew or should have known about the dangerous condition posed by the dog and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent harm.
    • Example: If a child is playing with a dog at a friend’s house and the dog bites someone, the property owner might be liable if they were aware of the dog’s presence and potential danger.

The Seriousness of Dog Bite Injuries

Dog bites can lead to severe injuries, requiring extensive medical treatment and resulting in significant financial and emotional consequences for victims. Some statistics highlight the gravity of dog bite injuries:

  1. Prevalence of Dog Bites:
    • According to the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), approximately 4.5 million dog bites occur in the United States each year.
    • Nearly 800,000 of these bites require medical attention.
  2. Children at Higher Risk:
    • The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that children are the most common victims of dog bites, with the highest incidence in children aged 5 to 9.
    • Children are more likely to suffer severe injuries from dog bites due to their smaller size and proximity to dogs.
  3. Severity of Injuries:
    • Dog bites can result in severe injuries such as deep lacerations, puncture wounds, infections, and nerve damage.
    • In some cases, dog bites can lead to long-term complications, including scarring, disfigurement, and psychological trauma.
  4. Economic Impact:
    • The Insurance Information Institute (III) states that in 2023, the average cost per dog bite claim in the United States was $58,545, reflecting the significant medical and legal expenses associated with these incidents.
    • Total payouts for dog bite claims nationwide exceeded $1.12 billion in the same year.

Legal Assistance and Steps to Take

  1. Consulting an Attorney
    • Legal Guidance: Victims of dog bites and their families should consult an experienced personal injury attorney to understand their rights and options. An attorney can help gather evidence, establish liability, and pursue compensation.
    • Case Evaluation: An attorney will evaluate the specifics of the case, including the dog’s history, the circumstances of the bite, and the roles of the involved parties.
  2. Documenting the Incident
    • Evidence Collection: It’s important to document the dog bite incident thoroughly. This includes taking photographs of the injuries, obtaining medical records, and gathering witness statements.
    • Report the Bite: Victims should report the dog bite to local animal control authorities, which can provide additional evidence and support the case.

In Illinois, determining liability for a dog bite when a child is in charge of the dog involves understanding the principles of strict liability under the Illinois Animal Control Act and considering potential negligence on the part of the child’s parents or guardians. Regardless of who was supervising the dog, the dog owner is typically held strictly liable. Consulting with an experienced personal injury attorney is essential to navigate the complexities of such cases and ensure that victims receive fair compensation for their injuries. If you or a loved one has been injured in a dog bite attack, contact the Naperville personal injury attorneys at John J. Malm & Associates to learn how you may be able to receive compensation for your injuries.

Contact Information